Sunderland
  Everton
Managers
(Sunderland)
(Everton)
Notes
Penalty Shoot-Out: SCOTT 1-0; Ball 1-1; JOHNSTON 2-1; Collins 2-2; SMITH 3-2; Materazzi 3-3; MAKIN (missed) 3-3; Oster (missed) 3-3; CLARK 4-3; Grant 4-4; QUINN 5-4; Bakayoko (saved) 5-4.
Goals
Michael Bridges 29  min
John Collins 74  min