1890 Aston Villa A 0 - 0

1891 Wolverhampton W. A 3 - 1

1892 Wolverhampton W. A 0 - 2

1894 West Bromwich A. A 2 - 0

1895 West Bromwich A. A 1 - 1

1896 Everton A 2 - 5

1899 Wolverhampton W. A 0 - 1

1900 Derby County A 1 - 1

1901 Liverpool A 1 - 0

1903 Newcastle United A 3 - 1

1904 Blackburn Rovers A 1 - 2

1907 Sheffield Wed. A 3 - 2

1908 Middlesbrough H 2 - 0

1910 Liverpool A 2 - 1

1911 Sheffield Wed. A 0 - 8

1912 Sheffield Wed. H 0 - 2

1913 Burnley H 1 - 1

1914 Newcastle United H 2 - 4

1919 West Bromwich A. A 0 - 4

1921 Everton H 1 - 2

1922 Stoke A 2 - 1

1923 Everton A 3 - 2

1924 Sheffield United A 1 - 2

1925 Huddersfield T. A 1 - 1

1927 Birmingham A 1 - 1

1928 Arsenal A 1 - 1

1929 Blackburn Rovers H 3 - 1

1930 Leicester City A 1 - 1

1931 Derby County A 1 - 3

1932 West Bromwich A. A 1 - 5

1933 Chelsea A 0 - 4

1934 Everton H 7 - 0

1935 Leeds United H 2 - 1

1936 Sheffield Wed. H 2 - 1

1938 Aston Villa H 1 - 5

1946 Wolverhampton W. A 1 - 2

1947 Everton A 0 - 3

1949 Stoke City H 3 - 0

1950 Manchester Utd A 5 - 3

1951 Newcastle United A 2 - 2

1952 Wolverhampton W. A 1 - 1

1953 Huddersfield T. A 1 - 2

1955 Newcastle United H 1 - 6

1957 Leeds United H 2 - 1

1958 Scunthorpe Utd A 2 - 3

1959 Lincoln City H 2 - 4

1960 Sheffield United H 1 - 1

1961 Charlton Ath. A 0 - 2

1962 Bury H 0 - 1

1963 Leeds United A 1 - 1

1964 Liverpool H 2 - 3

1966 Aston Villa H 2 - 1

1967 Newcastle United A 1 - 2

1968 Sheffield Wed. H 0 - 0

1969 Sheffield Wed. A 0 - 2

1970 Middlesbrough H 2 - 2

1973 Middlesbrough A 1 - 2

1974 York City H 2 - 0

1975 Hull City H 3 - 1

1977 Blackpool H 2 - 1

1978 Leicester City H 1 - 1

1979 Wrexham H 1 - 1

1980 West Bromwich A. H 0 - 0

1983 Everton A 0 - 0

1984 Everton H 1 - 2

1985 Sheffield United H 2 - 1

1986 Leeds United A 1 - 1

1987 Chester City A 2 - 1

1988 Barnsley H 1 - 0

1989 Oxford United H 1 - 0

1990 Crystal Palace A 1 - 2

1991 Tranmere Rovers A 0 - 1

1994 Bolton Wanderers H 1 - 1

1996 Derby County H 2 - 0

1997 Bradford City H 2 - 0

1998 Tranmere Rovers A 0 - 1

1999 Everton A 0 - 5

2000 Bradford City A 4 - 1

2001 Blackburn Rovers A 3 - 0

2002 Leeds United H 1 - 2

2003 Bradford City H 3 - 0

2004 Leeds United H 2 - 3

2005 Bolton Wanderers H 0 - 0

2006 Leeds United H 2 - 0

2007 Manchester Utd H 0 - 4

2008 Blackburn Rovers H 0 - 0

2009 Everton H 1 - 1

2010 Manchester Utd A 0 - 2

2011 Everton H 1 - 1

2012 Manchester City H 1 - 0

2013 Everton A 1 - 0

2014 Hull City H 1 - 3

2015 Manchester City A 1 - 4

2016 Manchester Utd A 1 - 3

2017 Sheffield United A 0 - 3

2018 Bradford City H 1 - 0

2019 Bolton Wanderers H 0 - 0

2022 Blackburn Rovers H 2 - 1

2023 Hull City A 1 - 0

1945 Burnley A 3 - 2

1942 Gateshead H 7 - 1

1944 Newcastle United A 1 - 3

1884 Erimus H 1 - 0

1885 North Eastern H 3 - 0

1887 Derby Junction H 4 - 0

1888 Druids H 12 - 0

1889 Halliwell H 10 - 1

1893 Everton A 1 - 4

1898 Celtic H 0 - 1

1918 Newcastle United H 1 - 0