Statistics are for First Class Competitions only
Sunderland
Sheffield United
 
 
Appearances
Apps (Goals)
 
 
Goalscorers
Goals (Apps)
 
 
Manager
Records
P-W-D-L-F-A
 
Ned Doig 23  
Arthur Bridgett 19   (7)
George Holley 18   (10)
Charlie Buchan 17   (12)
Billy Hogg 16   (3)
Billy Clunas 15   (1)
Len Ashurst 14  
Jimmy Gemmell 14   (3)
Charlie B. Thomson 14   (4)
Stan Anderson 13   (2)
Jimmy Watson 13  
Jimmy Millar 12   (2)
George Herd 11   (1)
Cecil Irwin 11  
Jimmy McNab 11   (1)
Bill Murray 11  
Tommy Tait 11  
Hughie Wilson 11   (1)
Kevin Ball 10   (1)
Frank Cuggy 10  
Billy Ellis 10   (1)
Harry Low 10  
Harry Martin 10   (1)
Colin McLatchie 10   (4)
George Mulhall 10   (3)
Gary Bennett 9   (2)
Johnny Campbell 9   (5)
Bobby Gurney 9   (5)
Dave Halliday 9   (7)
Charlie Hurley 9   (1)
Harry Shaw 9  
Jimmy Connor 8   (2)
Billy Elliott 8   (2)
Bobby Marshall 8   (1)
Len Shackleton 8   (2)
Arthur Wright 8   (1)
James Gillespie 7   (1)
John Poole 7  
Dusty Rhodes 7   (1)
Paul Bracewell 6   (1)
Lee Clark 6  
Ray Daniel 6   (1)
Len Duns 6   (2)
Patsy Gallacher 6   (2)
Arthur Hawes 6   (1)
Bobby Hogg 6   (2)
Neil Martin 6   (3)
Ted Purdon 6   (4)
Jim Baxter 5   (3)
Billy Bingham 5   (1)
Joe Devine 5  
Shaun Elliott 5   (1)
Donald Gow 5   (1)
Fred Hall 5  
Bobby Kerr 5   (1)
Jim Leslie 5   (2)
Gary Owers 5  
John Parke 5  
Jock Paterson 5   (1)
Jackie Robinson 5   (4)
Wilf Rostron 5   (4)
Marcus Stewart 5   (1)
Colin Todd 5  
Adam Allan 4  
Julio Arca 4  
Gary Breen 4   (1)
Michael Bridges 4   (2)
Arthur Brown 4   (1)
Harold Buckle 4   (1)
Joe Butler 4  
Billy Eden 4  
Charlie Fleming 4   (2)
Ambrose Fogarty 4   (3)
Marco Gabbiadini 4   (4)
Eric Gates 4   (1)
Colin Grainger 4   (2)
Billy Grimshaw 4   (1)
Harry Hood 4   (1)
Joe Kasher 4  
Kevin Kyle 4   (2)
Ian Lawther 4   (1)
Bob Lee 4   (3)
Sam Morris 4  
Harry Ness 4  
Jim Oakley 4  
John Oster 4  
Niall Quinn 4   (3)
Gary Rowell 4   (4)
Craig Russell 4   (1)
Barney Travers 4   (3)
John Auld 3  
Bobby Best 3  
Joe Bolton 3  
Ken Chisholm 3   (1)
Alf Common 3   (2)
Charlie Crossley 3   (2)
Bert Davis 3   (2)
Dickie Davis 3   (2)
Allan Gauden 3   (2)
Tim Gilbert 3   (1)
Frank Gray 3  
Phil Gray 3   (2)
Alex Hall 3  
John Harvey 3   (1)
James Hogg 3   (2)
Bob Kelly 3   (3)
Andy McCreadie 3   (2)
Joe McGhie 3  
Bobby McKay 3   (1)
Kevin Phillips 3   (3)
Mart Poom 3  
Jack Prior 3   (2)
Alex Rae 3   (1)
Tommy Reynolds 3   (1)
John Scott 3  
Nick Sharkey 3   (1)
Ernie Taylor 3   (2)
Jimmy Temple 3   (1)
Dave Wright 3   (1)
Benny Yorston 3   (1)
Tom Allan 2  
Phil Babb 2  
Phil Bach 2  
Paddy Bell 2  
Alan Brown 2   (1)
John Brown 2  
Raich Carter 2   (1)
Tim Coleman 2   (1)
Tom Daykin 2  
John Goodchild 2   (4)
Gordon Harris 2   (1)
Mel Holden 2  
Jack Huggins 2   (1)
Jack Jones 2  
John Kay 2  
Paul Lemon 2  
Angus McIntosh 2   (2)
Adam McLean 2   (1)
Willy McPheat 2   (1)
Tom Naisby 2  
Bobby Park 2  
Reg Pearce 2  
Sam Raybould 2   (2)
George Robinson 2   (1)
Ray Robinson 2   (1)
Joe Shaw 2   (1)
Tommy Smith 2   (2)
Colin Suggett 2   (2)
Bill Walsh 2  
Bob Ward 2  
Willie Watson 2   (1)
Ike Webb 2  
Albert Wood 2   (1)
Joel Asoro 1  
Joe Baker 1  
Tommy Becton 1   (1)
Frank Bee 1  
Ted Bell 1  
Alan Black 1  
Bob Bolder 1  
Lee Burge 1  
Tim Carter 1  
Tony Ford 1  
Gordon Gunson 1   (1)
Tom Hall 1  
Sam Kemp 1  
Stan Lloyd 1  
Joel Lynch 1  
Mark Lynch 1  
Josh Maja 1  
Jimmy McGuigan 1   (1)
Gary Moore 1   (1)
Max Power 1   (1)
Stan Ramsay 1   (1)
Jack Rodwell 1   (1)
John Rogers 1   (1)
Dickie Rooks 1   (1)
Ian Watson 1  
Dale White 1  
Bob Young 1  
John Young 1  
 
Charlie Buchan 12   (17)
George Holley 10   (18)
Dave Halliday 7   (9)
Arthur Bridgett 7   (19)
Johnny Campbell 5   (9)
Bobby Gurney 5   (9)
John Goodchild 4   (2)
Marco Gabbiadini 4   (4)
Gary Rowell 4   (4)
Jackie Robinson 4   (5)
Wilf Rostron 4   (5)
Ted Purdon 4   (6)
Colin McLatchie 4   (10)
Charlie B. Thomson 4   (14)
Bob Kelly 3   (3)
Kevin Phillips 3   (3)
Ambrose Fogarty 3   (4)
Bob Lee 3   (4)
Niall Quinn 3   (4)
Barney Travers 3   (4)
Jim Baxter 3   (5)
Neil Martin 3   (6)
George Mulhall 3   (10)
Jimmy Gemmell 3   (14)
Billy Hogg 3   (16)
Angus McIntosh 2   (2)
Sam Raybould 2   (2)
Tommy Smith 2   (2)
Colin Suggett 2   (2)
Alf Common 2   (3)
Charlie Crossley 2   (3)
Bert Davis 2   (3)
Dickie Davis 2   (3)
Allan Gauden 2   (3)
Phil Gray 2   (3)
James Hogg 2   (3)
Andy McCreadie 2   (3)
Jack Prior 2   (3)
Ernie Taylor 2   (3)
Michael Bridges 2   (4)
Charlie Fleming 2   (4)
Colin Grainger 2   (4)
Kevin Kyle 2   (4)
Jim Leslie 2   (5)
Len Duns 2   (6)
Patsy Gallacher 2   (6)
Bobby Hogg 2   (6)
Jimmy Connor 2   (8)
Billy Elliott 2   (8)
Len Shackleton 2   (8)
Gary Bennett 2   (9)
Jimmy Millar 2   (12)
Stan Anderson 2   (13)
Tommy Becton 1   (1)
Gordon Gunson 1   (1)
Jimmy McGuigan 1   (1)
Gary Moore 1   (1)
Max Power 1   (1)
Stan Ramsay 1   (1)
Jack Rodwell 1   (1)
John Rogers 1   (1)
Dickie Rooks 1   (1)
Alan Brown 1   (2)
Raich Carter 1   (2)
Tim Coleman 1   (2)
Gordon Harris 1   (2)
Jack Huggins 1   (2)
Adam McLean 1   (2)
Willy McPheat 1   (2)
George Robinson 1   (2)
Ray Robinson 1   (2)
Joe Shaw 1   (2)
Willie Watson 1   (2)
Albert Wood 1   (2)
Ken Chisholm 1   (3)
Tim Gilbert 1   (3)
John Harvey 1   (3)
Bobby McKay 1   (3)
Alex Rae 1   (3)
Tommy Reynolds 1   (3)
Nick Sharkey 1   (3)
Jimmy Temple 1   (3)
Dave Wright 1   (3)
Benny Yorston 1   (3)
Gary Breen 1   (4)
Arthur Brown 1   (4)
Harold Buckle 1   (4)
Eric Gates 1   (4)
Billy Grimshaw 1   (4)
Harry Hood 1   (4)
Ian Lawther 1   (4)
Craig Russell 1   (4)
Billy Bingham 1   (5)
Shaun Elliott 1   (5)
Donald Gow 1   (5)
Bobby Kerr 1   (5)
Jock Paterson 1   (5)
Marcus Stewart 1   (5)
Paul Bracewell 1   (6)
Ray Daniel 1   (6)
Arthur Hawes 1   (6)
James Gillespie 1   (7)
Dusty Rhodes 1   (7)
Bobby Marshall 1   (8)
Arthur Wright 1   (8)
Charlie Hurley 1   (9)
Kevin Ball 1   (10)
Billy Ellis 1   (10)
Harry Martin 1   (10)
George Herd 1   (11)
Jimmy McNab 1   (11)
Hughie Wilson 1   (11)
Billy Clunas 1   (15)
 
Robert Kyle 40   17   5   18   66   71
Bill Murray 14   7   4   3   28   21
Alex Mackie 13   6   3   4   17   13
Johnny Cochrane 13   5   4   4   25   27
Alan Brown 9   5   2   2   16   9
Peter Reid 9   5   2   2   14   6
Ian McColl 8   4   2   2   15   10
Tom Watson 7   4   1   2   12   9
Robert Campbell 6   2   0   4   4   8
Mick McCarthy 5   4   0   1   6   1
Denis Smith 4   2   1   1   6   3
Jimmy Adamson 4   1   1   2   9   7
Lawrie McMenemy 4   1   0   3   4   6
Billy Elliott 1   1   0   0   6   2
George Hardwick 1   1   0   0   3   1
Jack Ross 1   1   0   0   1   0
Mick Buxton 1   0   1   0   0   0
Chris Coleman 1   0   0   1   0   3
Selection Committee 1   0   0   1   0   3
Simon Grayson 1   0   0   1   1   2
Howard Wilkinson 1   0   0   1   0   2
 
Ernest Needham 29   (5)
George Green 22  
Fred Tunstall 22   (6)
Billy Gillespie 21   (4)
Bernard Wilkinson 20   (1)
Harry Johnson 18   (1)
Harry Johnson 17   (19)
Tommy Sampy 17   (1)
Fred Priest 16   (4)
Walter Bennett 14   (2)
Bob Benson 14   (1)
Bert Lipsham 14   (3)
Cec Coldwell 13  
Alan Woodward 13   (1)
Peter Boyle 12  
Bill Cook 12  
Harold Gough 12  
Wally Hardinge 12   (1)
Tommy Hoyland 12   (3)
Tom Morren 12  
Joe Shaw 12  
Len Birks 11  
Arthur Brown 11   (6)
Bob Cain 11  
Joe Kitchen 11   (3)
David Mercer 11   (2)
Ernest Milton 11   (1)
Jack Pickering 11   (8)
Len Badger 10  
Jimmy Dunne 10   (5)
Gil Reece 10   (4)
Graham Shaw 10  
Jim Simmons 10   (2)
Simon Tracey 10  
Bobby Evans 9   (1)
Stan Fazackerley 9   (3)
Jimmy Hagan 9   (6)
Bernard Oxley 9   (2)
Jack Smith 9  
Jack Almond 8   (2)
Billy Beer 8   (2)
Joe Brooks 8  
Mick Jones 8   (3)
Tony Wagstaff 8   (1)
Thomas Boyle 7   (2)
Ted Burgin 7  
Alonzo Drake 7   (1)
Harry Hammond 7   (3)
Vince Matthews 7   (1)
Reg Matthewson 7   (1)
Bobby Barclay 6   (1)
Brian Deane 6   (1)
Seth King 6  
Derek Pace 6   (3)
Ron Simpson 6   (1)
Harold Brook 5   (1)
Jimmy Donnelly 5   (2)
Bobby Ford 5  
Sid Gibson 5   (1)
Colin Grainger 5   (1)
Jim Iley 5  
Tony Kenworthy 5   (1)
Rob Kozluk 5  
Johnny Lang 5   (1)
Alf Ringstead 5   (2)
Wayne Allison 4   (1)
Ian Bryson 4   (2)
Alf Common 4  
Albert Cox 4  
Steve Foley 4   (1)
Willie Hamilton 4   (1)
Jon Harley 4  
Alan Kelly 4  
Jimmy Revill 4   (1)
Arthur Watson 4   (3)
Tony Agana 3  
Billy Batty 3   (1)
Edgar Bluff 3   (2)
Bob Booker 3  
Jack Cross 3   (2)
John Docherty 3   (1)
Keith Edwards 3   (2)
Andy Gray 3  
Derek Hawksworth 3   (1)
Colin Hill 3  
Robert Hill 3   (1)
Kevin Lewis 3   (1)
Marcelo 3   (1)
Bertie Menlove 3   (3)
Jim Plant 3  
Dean Saunders 3   (1)
Paul Shaw 3   (1)
Joe Smith 3  
Carl Veart 3  
Joe Walton 3  
Fred White 3  
Peter Withe 3   (1)
Dick Young 3  
Peter Anderson 2   (2)
Peter Beagrie 2   (2)
Bob Bolam 2   (1)
Fred Brown 2  
Bobby Campbell 2   (1)
Willie Carlin 2   (1)
John Cunningham 2   (1)
Joe Davies 2   (1)
Walter Davies 2   (1)
Mark Duffy 2  
Steve Finnieston 2   (3)
John Fleck 2  
David Frain 2   (1)
Kevin Gage 2  
Mick Guy 2  
Barry Hartle 2   (1)
Ted Helmsley 2   (1)
Mick Hill 2   (1)
Jim Holmes 2  
Ted Hufton 2  
Jack Jones 2  
John Lundstram 2   (1)
Lee Morris 2  
Bert Oswald 2   (1)
Jack Peart 2  
Tom Phillipson 2   (2)
Alan Quinn 2  
Walter Rickett 2   (1)
Alex Sabella 2   (1)
Bill Sampy 2  
Andy Scott 2  
Richard Stearman 2   (1)
Gareth Taylor 2   (1)
George Thompson 2   (1)
Mitch Ward 2  
Carl Asaba 1  
George Baldock 1   (1)
Mark Beard 1  
Frank Becton 1   (1)
Charlie Bell 1   (1)
Joe Bolton 1  
Willie Boyd 1   (1)
J. Brady 1  
George Bromage 1   (1)
Jim Brown 1  
Kean Bryan 1  
Phil Cliff 1  
Fred Davies 1   (1)
William Egan 1   (1)
Ched Evans 1  
Mel Eves 1  
John Flynn 1  
David Ford 1  
F. Gamble 1  
Nick Henry 1  
James Hobson 1   (1)
John Hope 1  
David Lee 1  
Joe McGhie 1  
Harry Mills 1   (1)
Shaun Murphy 1   (1)
Archie Needham 1   (1)
Percy Oldacre 1   (2)
Ben Osborn 1  
Eric Over 1  
John Reed 1  
Jackie Smith 1   (1)
Sam Thorpe 1  
Carl Tiler 1  
Mark Todd 1  
John Tudor 1  
Paul Wood 1  
 
Harry Johnson 19   (17)
Jack Pickering 8   (11)
Jimmy Hagan 6   (9)
Arthur Brown 6   (11)
Fred Tunstall 6   (22)
Jimmy Dunne 5   (10)
Ernest Needham 5   (29)
Gil Reece 4   (10)
Fred Priest 4   (16)
Billy Gillespie 4   (21)
Steve Finnieston 3   (2)
Bertie Menlove 3   (3)
Arthur Watson 3   (4)
Derek Pace 3   (6)
Harry Hammond 3   (7)
Mick Jones 3   (8)
Stan Fazackerley 3   (9)
Joe Kitchen 3   (11)
Tommy Hoyland 3   (12)
Bert Lipsham 3   (14)
Percy Oldacre 2   (1)
Peter Anderson 2   (2)
Peter Beagrie 2   (2)
Tom Phillipson 2   (2)
Edgar Bluff 2   (3)
Jack Cross 2   (3)
Keith Edwards 2   (3)
Ian Bryson 2   (4)
Jimmy Donnelly 2   (5)
Alf Ringstead 2   (5)
Thomas Boyle 2   (7)
Jack Almond 2   (8)
Billy Beer 2   (8)
Bernard Oxley 2   (9)
Jim Simmons 2   (10)
David Mercer 2   (11)
Walter Bennett 2   (14)
George Baldock 1   (1)
Frank Becton 1   (1)
Charlie Bell 1   (1)
Willie Boyd 1   (1)
George Bromage 1   (1)
Fred Davies 1   (1)
William Egan 1   (1)
James Hobson 1   (1)
Harry Mills 1   (1)
Shaun Murphy 1   (1)
Archie Needham 1   (1)
Jackie Smith 1   (1)
Bob Bolam 1   (2)
Bobby Campbell 1   (2)
Willie Carlin 1   (2)
John Cunningham 1   (2)
Joe Davies 1   (2)
Walter Davies 1   (2)
David Frain 1   (2)
Barry Hartle 1   (2)
Ted Helmsley 1   (2)
Mick Hill 1   (2)
John Lundstram 1   (2)
Bert Oswald 1   (2)
Walter Rickett 1   (2)
Alex Sabella 1   (2)
Richard Stearman 1   (2)
Gareth Taylor 1   (2)
George Thompson 1   (2)
Billy Batty 1   (3)
John Docherty 1   (3)
Derek Hawksworth 1   (3)
Robert Hill 1   (3)
Kevin Lewis 1   (3)
Marcelo 1   (3)
Dean Saunders 1   (3)
Paul Shaw 1   (3)
Peter Withe 1   (3)
Wayne Allison 1   (4)
Steve Foley 1   (4)
Willie Hamilton 1   (4)
Jimmy Revill 1   (4)
Harold Brook 1   (5)
Sid Gibson 1   (5)
Colin Grainger 1   (5)
Tony Kenworthy 1   (5)
Johnny Lang 1   (5)
Bobby Barclay 1   (6)
Brian Deane 1   (6)
Ron Simpson 1   (6)
Alonzo Drake 1   (7)
Vince Matthews 1   (7)
Reg Matthewson 1   (7)
Tony Wagstaff 1   (8)
Bobby Evans 1   (9)
Ernest Milton 1   (11)
Wally Hardinge 1   (12)
Alan Woodward 1   (13)
Bob Benson 1   (14)
Tommy Sampy 1   (17)
Harry Johnson 1   (18)
Bernard Wilkinson 1   (20)
 
John Nicholson 62   24   11   27   104   101
John Harris 18   5   4   9   22   30
J.B. Wostinholm 13   6   1   6   17   16
Teddy Davison 10   4   2   4   18   21
Dave Bassett 7   1   2   4   3   9
Neil Warnock 6   2   0   4   3   6
Joe Mercer 5   0   1   4   5   11
Reg Freeman 4   1   2   1   6   7
Billy McEwan 3   3   0   0   5   2
Harry Haslam 3   2   0   1   7   9
Chris Wilder 3   2   0   1   5   2
Nigel Spackman 2   1   0   1   4   4
Steve Thompson 2   1   0   1   2   3
Steve Bruce 2   0   1   1   0   4
Howard Kendall 1   0   1   0   0   0
Jimmy Sirrel 1   0   1   0   1   1
Cec Coldwell 1   0   0   1   1   5
Ian Porterfield 1   0   0   1   1   2